ANDREW GARFIELD - only like icons from this show, not many icons that I like
LOGAN LERMAN - looks too much like Zefron (which is never a bad thing, but I love Zefron too much to ever PB him)
CHRIS MARQUETTE - doesn't smile enough, makes me want to watch Joan of Arcadia (which would just be a distraction from RPing)
The guys I love and have to decide between
WILLIAM BECKETT He is adorable!!! Icons might be too rock star? (Though LJ only has, what, 15? So that might be able to slide.)
JOSEPH GORDON-LEVITT I have had a crush on this guy forever. I can't think of any negatives for using him. Plus, I'd be able to use him for a long time (or in any age-up instances), since he has older-looking icons as well.
PATRICK FUGIT Who I always cast as Pete Black in my mind. Icon quality varies, but again, LJ has the limit.